Healthcare Fraud in Measurement and Value-Based Payment Contracts
A Discussion Paper
…offering misleading contracts to providers, which causes them to bill government programs based on false premises, further extends the fraudulent activity. Providers may then unknowingly submit claims for services under terms that are not accurate or ethical. The health plan's actions lead to the improper allocation of taxpayer funds, diverting money from legitimate healthcare services to fraudulent schemes.
Examples of healthcare fraud in this scenario include a Healthplan falsely reporting compliance with Federal, State and Industry value-based care guidelines and standards to obtain funding from state programs, despite knowing that their contracts do not meet these standards.
Healthcare fraud involves the intentional deception or misrepresentation made by an individual or entity in a healthcare transaction that could result in unauthorized benefit or payment. This can include false claims, kickbacks, misrepresentation of services, and fraudulent billing practices. When a Healthplan misrepresents the nature of its contracts to secure funding from the state, and these contracts are based on misleading and unethical terms offered to providers of Medicare, Medicaid, or other government healthcare programs, it constitutes healthcare fraud. This fraudulent activity involves several layers:
By misrepresenting contract terms, the Healthplan is submitting false information to obtain funds from state or federal programs. This can include inflated claims about compliance with value-based care standards or the scope of services provided. Additionally, offering misleading contracts to providers, which causes them to bill government programs based on false premises, further extends the fraudulent activity. Providers may unknowingly submit claims for services under terms that are not accurate or ethical. The health plan's actions lead to the improper allocation of taxpayer funds, diverting money from legitimate healthcare services to fraudulent schemes.
Healthplans may falsely represent the effectiveness, compliance, and outcomes associated with their value-based contracts to secure funding. This misrepresentation can include exaggerated claims about their adherence to care standards and the benefits they provide, which are used to justify the receipt of state or federal funds. The Healthplan might offer contracts to providers that are inherently misleading, promising certain benefits or reimbursement rates that are not actually delivered. This causes providers to submit claims based on these false premises, affecting the integrity of claims submitted to Medicare, Medicaid, and other government programs. Additionally, Healthplans may manipulate data and performance metrics to favor their financial interests. By selectively withholding comprehensive data and presenting skewed information, they create a false narrative that supports their funding claims, impacting the negotiations and contractual agreements with providers and government programs.
Examples of healthcare fraud in this scenario include a Healthplan falsely reporting compliance with Federal, State and Industry value-based care guidelines and standards to obtain funding from state programs, despite knowing that their contracts do not meet these standards. Healthplans may also offer contracts to providers that misrepresent reimbursement rates and terms, causing providers to unknowingly submit fraudulent claims to government programs. Moreover, health plans might train AI systems to audit provider records in a biased manner, emphasizing cost-saving measures over accurate clinical outcomes, leading to unjust denials of legitimate claims and creating financial incentives based on false data.
The described actions by the Healthplan, including misrepresenting the nature of contracts to obtain state funding and offering misleading and unethical contracts to providers, constitute healthcare fraud. This fraudulent activity not only diverts taxpayer dollars from legitimate healthcare services but also undermines the integrity of the healthcare system. Identifying and addressing such fraud is essential to protect public resources and ensure the provision of ethical and effective healthcare services.
DISCLAIMER and PURPOSE: This discussion document is intended for training, educational, and or research purposes only. The information contained herein is based on the data and perspectives available at the time of writing. It is subject to revision as new information and viewpoints emerge.
For more information see: https://www.mentorresearch.org/disclaimer-and-purpose